up [0] down

Evidence Relationship: Opposes

Proposed by SonOfPeleus (202) 3 months, 3 weeks ago

Vote on whether "Fire is a form of oxidation" is good evidence that opposes the claim "Fire is caused by the release of phlogiston"

Sources for this evidence:

Evidence Claim

Fire is a form of oxidation

Fire is the chemical reaction between oxygen and a fuel.

by SonOfPeleus (202) 3 months, 3 weeks ago

Main Claim

Fire is caused by the release of phlogiston

During combustion, particles of fire, known as phlogiston, is released from the the combustible material.

by SonOfPeleus 3 months, 3 weeks ago
SonOfPeleus (202) 3 months, 3 weeks ago | up / down [0]

This is a correct statement opposing an incorrect claim, however, it supposes knowledge that was discovered after the refutation of the phlogiston theory of combustion.