SonOfPeleus 239

26 claims · 0 supported · 0 refuted · 26 open · 25 evidence links · 0 respondeo

joined October 2025 · rank #2 of 98

on Circular Reasoning Works · +1 · 11 months ago

Was unable to cite this claim in support of it self. Touche.
on Antoine-Laurent de Lavoisier proved this is false · 0 · 11 months ago

Multiple claims are using this claim as evidence. If it's edited to correct the Argument from Authority, it may not work for every claim where it is used as evidence. …
on Antoine-Laurent de Lavoisier proved this is false · 0 · 11 months ago

The description is making an argument from authority. It could be edited to correct it, but the tag would remain. In this case, the tag could be deleted, but what …
on Phlogiston Theory is a debunked 18th century scientific theory · 0 · 11 months ago

The claim "Antoine-Laurent..." should support the main claim, but is worded ambiguously. If it is edited, it may affect other claims that use it as evidence.
on Antoine-Laurent de Lavoisier proved this is false for Phlogiston Theory is a debunked 18th century scientific theory · 0 · 11 months ago

This claim should support the main claim, but is worded ambiguously. If it is edited, it may affect other claims that use it as evidence.
on Merriam-Webster defines combustion as a usually rapid chemical process (such as oxidation) that produces heat and usually light for Combustion requires oxygen · 0 · 11 months ago

This is a true statement, but inappropriate as evidence for this claim.
on April is the cruelest month for Fire is caused by the release of phlogiston · 0 · 11 months ago

This is irrelevant to the argument
on Wood weighs less after combustion · 0 · 11 months ago

The title and the description are making distinct claims. The description adds a cause to the claim of the title. How can we evaluate the claim in the title independently …
on Combusted substances weigh less than their pre-combusted states · 0 · 11 months ago

In this case, the point is moot because the both claims are false.
on Combusted substances weigh less than their pre-combusted states · 0 · 11 months ago

The title and the description are making distinct claims. The description adds a cause to the claim of the title. How can we evaluate the claim in the title independently …
on Combusted substances weigh less than their pre-combusted states · +1 · 11 months ago

Was able to add the same claim to both sides of the argument
on Combusted substances weigh less than their pre-combusted states · 0 · 11 months ago

Accidentally added the claim to supporting evidence instead of opposing evidence. Cannot remove it.
on Fire is a form of oxidation against Fire is caused by the release of phlogiston · 0 · 11 months ago

This is a correct statement opposing an incorrect claim, however, it supposes knowledge that was discovered after the refutation of the phlogiston theory of combustion.
on FTC Decision and Order against Kellogg Company · 0 · 11 months ago

I would like to attach a link to a video in support of a claim, but there's no way to do it without a creating a claim. I made a …
on FTC Decision and Order against Kellogg Company against Frosted Mini-Wheats has been clinically shown to improve children’s attentiveness by nearly 20 percent when compared to children who ate no breakfast · 0 · 11 months ago

I would like to attach a link to a pdf in opposition to a claim, but there's no way to do it without a creating a claim. I made a …
on Frosted Mini Wheats Commercial (2009) for Frosted Mini-Wheats has been clinically shown to improve children’s attentiveness by nearly 20 percent when compared to children who ate no breakfast · 0 · 11 months ago

I would like to attach a link to a video in support of a claim, but there's no way to do it without a creating a claim. I made a …
on Frosted Mini Wheats Commercial (2009) · 0 · 11 months ago

I would like to attach a link to a video in support of a claim, but there's no way to do it without a creating a claim. I made a …